Memory bandwidth and latency constitutes a major performance bottleneck for many data-intensive applications. While high-locality access patterns take advantage of the deep cache hierarchies available in modern processors, unpredictable low-locality patterns cause a significant part of the execution time to be wasted waiting for data. An example of those memory bound applications is the exact matching algorithm based on FM-index, used in some well-known sequence alignment applications. Processing-Near-Memory (PNM) has been proposed as a strategy to overcome the memory wall problem, by placing computation close to data, speeding up memory bound workloads by reducing data movements.
This paper presents a performance and energy evaluation of two classes of processor architectures when executing the FM-index exact matching algorithm, as a reference algorithm for exact sequence alignment. One architecture class is processor-centric, based on complex cores and DDR3/4 SDRAM memory technology. The other architecture class is memory-centric, based on simple cores and ultra high-bandwidth Hybrid Memory Cube (HMC) 3D-stacked memory technology. The results show that the PNM solution improves performance between 1.26× and 3.7× and the energy consumption per operation is reduced between 21× and 40×.
In addition, a synthetic benchmark RANDOM was developed that mimics the memory access pattern of the FM-index exact matching algorithm, but with a user configurable operational intensity. This benchmark allows us to extend the evaluation to the class of algorithms with similar memory behaviour but running over a range of operational intensity values.
